How to pick a virtual challenge you will actually finish

Updated · 6 min read

A woman writes on a whiteboard calendar hanging on her kitchen wall
Photo: Sable Flow / Unsplash

In short: Pick a virtual challenge by working backwards from your real week. Look at how often you walk or run now, then divide the challenge distance by its window to get a daily average. If that average fits into a normal day with room to spare, it is the right size. Then check the calendar for travel and busy weeks, and plan to finish a few days early. A challenge you finish beats a bigger one you abandon.

Start from what you do now

The best predictor of what you will do next month is what you did last month. Be honest about it. Then match it to a challenge that asks a little more, not a lot more.

A realistic first challenge for each starting point
Where you are nowA realistic first pickWhy
Mostly sitting, little exerciseLoki, 5 km in 7 daysA short window and a short daily walk
Walking a few times a weekKylin, 88 km in 68 daysThe lowest daily average, 1.3 km, over a long stretch
Running or walking 3 times a weekOdin or ThorA clear distance with a window of under three weeks
Already running 20 km or more a weekDragon, 179 km in 88 daysThe biggest total, and a test of consistency over a season

Do the daily math

The total sounds scary. The daily number is what you actually live with. Here is every X Challenge broken down.

Every X Challenge as a daily average, with the walk it takes at about 3 miles an hour
ChallengeDistanceWindowPer dayDaily walk
Loki5 km (3.1 mi)7 days0.7 km (0.4 mi)About 10 min
Odin10 km (6.2 mi)10 days1 km (0.6 mi)About 15 min
Thor21 km (about 13 mi)20 days1.1 km (0.7 mi)About 15 min
Turtle68 km (42 mi)39 days1.7 km (1.1 mi)About 25 min
Kylin88 km (55 mi)68 days1.3 km (0.8 mi)About 20 min
Phoenix139 km (86 mi)79 days1.8 km (1.1 mi)About 25 min
Dragon179 km (111 mi)88 days2 km (1.3 mi)About 30 min

U.S. health guidance suggests about 150 minutes a week of moderate activity such as brisk walking, and it can be split into shorter chunks. Every challenge above sits within reach of that if you walk most days.

Check your calendar

Open your calendar for the length of the window and look for trouble: trips, a work deadline, a houseguest, the holidays. One busy week inside a short window can sink it. Inside a long window it barely matters.

On X Challenge the window starts when you tap Start, not when you buy, so you can buy now and start after the busy stretch. See when to start a virtual challenge.

Pick the activity you will really do

If you do not enjoy running, do not plan to run. Any activity the X Challenge app records distance for counts: walking, hiking, a treadmill, cycling, swimming or rowing. A 30-minute bike ride covers far more ground than a 30-minute walk, which makes the long challenges much easier for people who ride.

Leave a buffer

Plan to finish with about a quarter of the window to spare. Something always comes up: a cold, a storm, a late night at work. If your plan needs every single day, it is too tight.

  • Loki: aim to finish in 6 days.
  • Thor: aim to finish in 15 days.
  • Kylin: aim to finish in 51 days.
  • Dragon: aim to finish in 66 days.

Three worked examples

Maria walks the dog for 15 minutes most evenings and has never run. Her normal week already holds about 1.2 km a day. Kylin at 1.3 km a day asks only a little more: one longer walk on the weekend. She picks it, starts after a work trip, and finishes with a week to spare.

James runs 3 miles twice a week and wants a stretch goal. Thor needs about 7.4 km a week, a little less than he already runs. The stretch is keeping it up for 20 days without a skipped week, and saying he covered a half marathon distance. He starts on a Monday with no travel for a month.

Priya works shifts and some weeks she cannot move at all. A short window is risky for her, so she picks Dragon: 88 days at 2 km a day. On free days she cycles 10 km and banks it, and her busy weeks cost her nothing she cannot make up.

Pick a medal you want to look at

Once the distance fits, let the medal decide. On the days you do not feel like going out, the thing you are working toward matters. If the Norse gods of Legends Of Asgard speak to you, that is a reason to pick one. If the dragon or the phoenix of The Four Holy Beasts does, pick that instead. See what makes a good finisher medal and all challenges.

One challenge or a whole set?

Buying a collection up front costs less than buying each medal separately: Legends Of Asgard is $99 for three, and The Four Holy Beasts is $129 for four, against $45 each on their own. It also commits you to more. If this is your first virtual challenge, try one and see how the format fits your weeks. If you already know you like it, the set gives you the next goal before the last one ends, and each challenge still starts only when you tap Start.

If it goes wrong partway

Even a well-chosen challenge can hit a bad week. Do not try to fix it in one long day. Work out what is left, divide it by the days left, and add one session a week. If an illness or emergency makes finishing impossible, write to info@xchallenge.us before the window ends. Without a recorded finish, no medal ships.

A three-question test

  1. Could I cover the daily average on a bad day, tired and short of time? If not, go smaller.
  2. Is there a week in the window where I will not move at all? If so, start later or pick a longer window.
  3. Will I still care about this goal in week three? If not, pick a shorter window or a medal you really want.

Common mistakes

  • Choosing by the medal alone, then finding the window does not fit your life.
  • Basing the plan on your best week instead of a normal one.
  • Going from nothing straight to daily runs. Beginner plans such as Couch to 5K build up over about nine weeks with rest days in between.
  • Starting a short challenge right before a trip.

Common questions

  • Is Loki too easy? For some people. It is meant as a first finish and a way to learn your rhythm.
  • Should I buy a collection up front? If you already know you like the format, yes. If not, try one challenge first.
  • What if I picked too big? Divide what is left by the days left and add sessions, or write to support before the window ends.

If you have a health condition, are pregnant, or have not exercised in a long time, check with a doctor before you start.

Sources

Challenges from this guide

More: all guides · how it works · every challenge